July 16, 2007

Evangelion Vol. 11

Volume eleven of the Evangelion manga tells the events of the first third or so of End of Evangelion, meaning the manga has decided to follow the film's continuity rather than the controversial TV ending. Its key differences lie in the minutia rather than any catastrophic deviation from the canon. But it's enough, as usual, to legitimise the manga next to its animated counter-part. These differences are mostly alternative methods of getting to the same point, and more often than not the manga actively neuters most of the disturbing aspects of the anime's finale.

For example, Kaworu's death doesn't end with that dramatic splash of water, and Shinji doesn't masturbate over a catatonic Asuka. In fact, in that particular scene, Asuka goes hysterical and attempts to choke Shinji (and rather bloody satisfying it is, too). But these modified moments don't hamper the manga's impact. Granted, they don't systematically wear your emotional state to tatters - one of the many perverse pleasures of the film - but they fit perfectly with the approach the manga has been taking from the outset. Sadamoto has been subtly doing it his way since chapter one, and even at this pinnacle stage he honours the small but important changes he's made.

In the manga Shinji has always been slightly stronger of will than the trembling wimp portrayed in the anime, and in these final moments his mental well-being is nowhere near the level of despondency as his film counterpart. The key reason for this, I think, is because manga Shinji's relationship with Kaworu never developed the same intense connection (with Sadamoto implying that his Shinji thought Kaworu to be a bit of a smug twat) so his death didn't drive Shinji to the same level of despair. This is refreshing in many ways, but it does a lot to undermine the subsequent events. Shinji's apathy as SEELE descend on NERV for the final showdown just doesn't have the same convincing sense of hopelessness as the film, and as a result we question why Shinji is refusing to fight when it was indisputable in EoE. The manga ends as the SEELE troops leave on their mission to assassinate the Children and I'm curious to see how Shinji reacts when they place a gun to his head. Perhaps he will beg for his life and Misato will save him earlier. I really can't imagine it working in the same way as its source; it would undo much of the unique approach Sadamoto has been working on from the start.

This was a very readable volume and the manga remains the perfect compliment to the anime. Sadamoto's art remains godlike and his reimagining of some key scenes holds all the dramatic poignancy of the anime while having enough personality to differentiate. My only wish now is that the manga's conclusion depicts Instrumentality as a combination of the event of the film and the TV ending, and builds a bridge between to the two, finally laying to rest the intense schism they've caused in Eva fandom. I'm also very curious to see if Rebuild has any affect on the manga. I doubt it will, but Sadamoto has dragged this thing on long enough for it to be rather serendipitous. Perhaps he'll continue it on to tell the events of the new films. How cheeky and irritating would that be?

May 06, 2006

Neon Genesis Evangelion Stage 71 Review

Author: Yoshiyuki Sadamoto
Publisher: YOUNG Magazine
Source: Raw scan and translation by 'M'

03I could open with a prolonged gush about my love for Evangelion; the draft before this had a hundred word introduction doing just that until I realized I wasn't saying anything that hadn't been said before. Yep, I love Evangelion for exactly the same reasons you probably love Evangelion. No end of personal accounts could really differentiate my experience from anyone else's, so lets just suffice to say that Evangelion is special.

So the question is: does the manga honour the show, or even compliment it? All the important boxes are ticked, most of which revolve around Yoshiyuki Sadamoto - mangaka and Gainax elite - and I'm inclined to say this one of the best anime to manga adaptations around (though I'd be the first to point out that the manga technically came first). More often than not Eva the manga has supplemented the anime with wholly relevant and interesting material. Granted, conversely, it could be said that Sadamoto has merely pandered to the otaku by giving us more Kaji and more Kaworu, but this is unfair. Each of these diversions from the original work has been solidly entertaining and enlightening stuff. It's rarely felt like Sadamoto was deviating from the original - simply filling in the gaps, cutting away a lot of the chaff that dogged the anime (i.e. the monster-a-week format). There have been some fairly major differences in story-telling, with Gendou ingesting Adam in this Stage serving as an example of that, but ultimately these are irrelevant. Evangelion the manga is a worthy companion to its legendary sibling.

23Stage 71 deals with the later part of the series - around episode 24 of the anime. Ritsuko has destroyed the dummy plug, Kaworu has received his orders from SEELE and Gendou is preparing for Instrumentality. Misato recounts the day of the Second Impact and Shinji gradually realises he has no one left. Consequently, this latter part gives rise to one of the most appealing aspects of the manga so far: Shinji's massively different relationship with Kaworu. After Kaworu's previous attempted advances (yes, those kind of advances) on Shinji he no longer considers Kaworu a friend and discards him appropriately. Rather than taking the 'loved-lost' approach of the anime Sadamoto seems to be playing the out-right isolation card for Shinji, suggesting a much more muted descent for the forthcoming Instrumentality. I genuinely respect Sadamoto for taking this route; it partly addresses much of the controversy over Shinji and Kaworu's relationship and spins it on its head while making a clear, definite break from the anime. These subtle (and no-so-subtle) breaks from the original are what make Evangelion's manga such essential reading for Eva fans.

And then there's the artwork. I'll admit it outright: Sadamoto is my Art God. Evangelion, FLCL (especially FLCL), the .hack series. The man is at the top of his game. And his seminal manga effort never, never disappoints. Even if it was substandard story-wise, which it clearly isn't, his artwork could carry it beyond most other work of this kind. The sequential order is lucid and expressive; the character design moreso, and the composition of each panel is simply clear and beautifully rendered. I still kick myself for not buying Der Mond, Sadamoto's artbook, when Viz still published it. If I had the £140 it seems to go for these days I'd buy it in a minute. The man just inspires verbose fanboy love like few others.

So apart from the appalling wait between each chapter, this is fantastic stuff. The closer we edge to the final moments the more I keenly anticipate Sadamoto's take on Instrumentality. Will it be a gratuitous mindfuck of End of Evangelion proportions, or a considered abstract Eva TV approach? Regardless, it promises to be breathtaking. Only another three or four months until the next Stage, eh?

December 20, 2005

Neon Genesis Evangelion Platinum Box Set (Thinpak) Review

Director: Hideki Anno Publisher: ADV, Star Child DVD NTSC Region 1

Package Description
Eva Platinum Box SetThis boxset features six volumes encased in the extra-thin style DVD cases, each featuring the spangly new cover artwork by Sadamoto seen on the original NGE Platinum releases (except for volume seven’s Kaworu due to the obvious lack of a seventh volume). The box itself is similar to the original box set container only smaller, made with sturdy cardboard featuring Asuka and Rei in the artwork and metalic silver finish. Each DVD itself has five episodes of the series, apart from volume five which has six (accommodating for episode 26) and volume six of the collection features the director’s cut editions of episode 21 – 24 in full. Every single episode (including the DC versions) is fully remastered visually and audibly and there are no other extras previously seen in the single Platinum releases; purely the episodes alone with the option between the English language track or Japanese with subtitles.

General Thoughts
Exactly what I’ve always wanted for one of the seminal anime series and of course, like most fans, a personal favourite. Not being able to quite afford keeping up with the single releases of this beautifully remastered edition of the show, this thinpak suits both my wallet and my general ethos on how DVDs should be. It cuts away a lot of the chaff of the original release, which to be fair was quite attractive and occasionally useful, but ultimately nothing the internet couldn’t provide in abundance. And after volume one’s ‘director’s commentary’ (Eva fanboys smirk cynically) with Mark Greenfield and Spike Spenser (both involved with the English dub from ADV) I felt I wasn’t missing anything important by not having that. Yeah, this stripped down, bare essentials release is exactly what people who simply want the remastered version of NGE in an attractive package will get. Top marks to ADV for doing this with style and extra kudos for including the director’s cut episodes on their own disc.

The remaster of the visuals and sound themselves is fantastic. Do a google search for comparative studies on the subject for more practical examples, but in my casually superficial opinion I was surprised by the subtle but noticeable improvement on both accounts. The colours are as vibrant and expressive as we presume the very first masters of the show would’ve been in 1995 and the sound is crystal clear. Sadly my audio set-up couldn’t take advantage of the 5.1 but I’m sure Anime on DVD & co can give a better, more informed view of that side of things. Needless to say as a casual viewer with an eye for quality I was thoroughly impressed. This is definitely one of the more rewarding aspects of milking the Eva cashcow, although I dread to think of what might come next . . .

One notable thought I had as I watched the series was how the new paint job brought the TV series more inline with the film visually. I always had a small niggling feeling that the film just had that nicer sheen to its presentation than the series and settled with the explanation that the film had a higher budget and thus obvious reason to look better. But with the advent of the Platinum shinification of the series the two entities mesh much more effectively, and so End of Evangelion works less jarringly as an alternative version of episodes 25 and 26.

The one criticism I can level at the collection is a small tear that appeared on one of the DVD boxes’ plastic-film covering at the lower corner where the box bends as you open it. It’s only happened on one of them and I’m hoping it’s just an isolated case, but I can foresee a problem with continued use. Hopefully ADV haven’t cut corners by using less durable plastic coverings for this release, as it’s the only problem I can find with an otherwise stellar output. Worth the bucks, for sure.

About

  • Avid otaku resistance in the face of indisputable fanboyism. Love for fringe anime, assorted manga and numerous other Japanese diversions.

    While I try to avoid them, there may be SPOILERS in my posts, so keep that in mind before you read.

    Anime Nano Profile
    Livejournal syndication


    AnimeSeen profile

Listening